331Erock or FamillyJules7X?

by **Soylent Blue** Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:25 pm

https://www.youtube.com/user/331Erock

https://www.youtube.com/user/FamilyJules7X#p/u

Don't judge by who they are, judge by their guitar skills.

by **NAT** Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:37 pm

I KNEW someone was going to make this!

by **TheOrangeDart** Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:37 pm

My vote goes to Jules, because he keeps to the song he's covering.
He doesn't add some crazy ass solo.
Watching Erock I was like "AWW YEAH! THAT GAME!!!" but after the main theme goes by he breaks into his own solo and its not even remotely the same song any more.
That, and Jules has more instruments going on. You can hear them all clearly. Lead guitar, other guitars, bass, drum machine, and it's all clear as a bell to hear.
Erock's you can hear the lead guitar, but everything else is pushed into the background.
Another reason, is Jules uses much better editing. Like camera views and angles. Erock is one camera in 1 spot.
ALSO, Jules plays all his instruments besides the drums.

I could go on forever. Erock is really damn good, don't get me wrong. But, Jules does it better.

by **Soylent Blue** Sun Aug 28, 2011 8:56 pm

His "crazy ass solos" are what makes his music feel like more than just a cover. Even if electric guitar is the only thing he plays, the way he plays it makes up for it.

And the fact that he only needs one instrument to get his songs across makes him even more epic in my opinion. I just like Erock's sound better.

by **TheOrangeDart** Sun Aug 28, 2011 9:07 pm

One instrument and a drum machine don't cut it for me. That's +1 talent.
A guitar, sometimes played in several different edits, a bass guitar, sometimes a keyboard, even one time a stand up bass, that's like +5 talent.

Comparing these 2 artists is actually a little bit pointless. It's like comparing Mario to Sonic.
One is strictly videos games, while the other is anything with his own stuff mixed in.

A better comparison would be FamilyJules7X and CSGuitar89. They're virtually the same subject so it's more reasonable.

by **NAT** Sun Aug 28, 2011 10:16 pm

TheOrangeDart wrote:Comparing these 2 artists is actually a little bit pointless. It's like comparing Mario to Sonic.

Yet, they're still rivals because of differences...
Some people like Mario for the classic platforming feel while others like Sonic for the high speed and intense rush of action packed stages (While still being a platformer).
Use this as a comparison for the two different people on here and decide on what you like best.

by **TheOrangeDart** Mon Aug 29, 2011 12:03 am

NAT wrote:
TheOrangeDart wrote:Comparing these 2 artists is actually a little bit pointless. It's like comparing Mario to Sonic.
Yet, they're still rivals because of differences...
Some people like Mario for the classic platforming feel while others like Sonic for the high speed and intense rush of action packed stages (While still being a platformer).
Use this as a comparison for the two different people on here and decide on what you like best.

That's just it though. Comparing 2 different things.
Might as well be like "Which is better: NES or Xbox360?!!"
Same subject, but different things.